One Size Does Not Fit All
One of my colleagues recently asked me if I heard that some Principals were going to be removed from schools as a result of events that have occurred in their schools. This has been a very turbulent school year for many high school Principals, including myself. Between managing the climate, keeping up with the changing directives of upper management, and managing to continue to focus on improving instruction, my own school keeps me so busy that there is no time to worry about what goes on in other schools. With all of the recent turbulence and changes, I began to really think about exactly what are schools responsible for and what should they be responsible for. What are the specific responsibilities of educators and how far reaching should a school be in the life of a child?
According to the dictionary school is “an institution for teaching children, a department specializing in an academic subject, and an instructive place or period.” When used as a verb, “school” develops a person’s skills or discipline. So school by definition is a place that educates people in a skill or discipline. However, in my school’s case many students do not come prepared to receive the instruction that will benefit them upon graduation. Unfortunately, many of the “interventions” that are put in place to help them are often “one size fits all” solutions that are often of a nature that further contributes to the low self-esteem that already exists among many of our at-risk students. However, when working in the context of a school district, one must fully understand the system and the academic and behavioral programs and procedures that must followed and must be willing to implement them in a way that meets the requirements and expectations of that district whether we agree with them or not. Unlike a charter or private school, we do not always get to choose the course of our ship in the public school system. However, what we do get to choose is the level of innovation, creativity, and care with which implement these programs.
While some programs are simply scripted, or prescribed, the large majority of what we teach is open to the type of innovation and creativity that can engage and excite even the hardest to reach students and helps them move forward academically. This, of course, requires teachers to work harder, longer, and stronger in schools such as ours. To be an effective teacher in an urban school environment requires a level of personal commitment in a teacher that is often not required in some “easier” school environments and a recognition that many times our students are the victims of chronic failure because they were disengaged in the process of education at an early age, if they were ever engaged at all, and that along with instruction in content must come direct instruction in the role they play in the educational process. It is difficult for a child to understand what their obligation is in this process when they have spent years as a bystander in their own education in a system that has failed them. The task of re-engaging the chronically disengaged is a challenge that must be met with a type of relentless innovation and creativity that is found by those who choose to accept this challenge wholeheartedly.
So what is the responsibility of a school to a child? Administrators and teachers in urban schools have complicated and complex jobs. Administrators must take the limited resources and programs they are given and make them work in a way that maximizes their benefits. Teachers must take what they are given and innovate it in a way that reaches the wide range of what makes up our classrooms while at the same time meeting district requirements. Both parties must constantly re-train and re-shape the thinking and overall mindset of the young people around us who have fallen victim to a passive education and the chronic underperformance that many times have plagued their families, their schools, and their community for generations. Families and students must also learn to understand and accept their role in the process as well even if that means traveling in unknown waters with them upstream in a boat with no oars. Sadly enough, this concept is new to many of our families and students after so many years of experiences with uncaring institutional like school settings that work on a foundation of punitive (i.e., truancy court, discipline transfers, etc.) actions rather than a caring school environment that is willing to repeatedly reinforce positive involvement and the development of positive educational habits. It is not always easy for families and students to get this message, for it is an unusual approach to the usual problems. It is a message that is often poorly received or misunderstood by our particular audience and one that must be reinforced repeatedly and without reservation time and time again. Many times at the end of the day we have to cut our losses and settle up our wins. Where we may have failed to engage the whole, each day there are individual wins in hallways and lunchrooms and classrooms and there are always individual children and families who have undoubtedly been changed by our efforts. When attempting to change the course of a ship that has been traveling in the same direction for many years, individual wins are to be celebrated. Over time, the collective individual wins are what really have the potential to make a difference because one size really does not fit all.
